Western experts are weighing in on Chinese whistle-blower Dr. Li-Meng Yan’s report claiming to show COVID-19 was man-made in a lab — with several dismissing it as more of a theoretical think piece that offers no new evidence and includes flawed research.
“One of the major arguments [in the paper] is that [the virus] is so unique, it can’t have been generated naturally, the only explanation is that it’s man-made,” Dr. Gary Whittaker, a professor of virology at Cornell University’s College of Veterinary Medicine, told The Post. “I would push back on that.”
Yan’s report, published late Monday on the website Zenote, says Sars-Cov-2’s unique genome shows it was created in a lab because the specific sequences of the mystery bug aren’t found in nature.
Jason Kaelber, a Rutgers University virologist and an assistant research professor at the Institute for Quantitative Biomedicine, said that’s simply not the case.
“All the weird things about Sars-Cov-2 are completely consistent with the sort of weirdness that happens in wild viruses all the time,” Kaelber told The Post.
“One reason why I haven’t gone looking for explanations of artificial origins is because we knew something like this was going to happen sooner or later,” he continued, citing the recent Zika virus outbreak and MERS in 2012, among others.
“This one is the worst since AIDS but it’s not the first and it won’t be the last. So if all the labs in the world shut down, these things would keep coming.”
Kaelber said Yan writes significantly about an apparent “restriction site” on the virus’s genome — a place where a scientist could cut out a piece from a naturally occurring bug and insert something man made — and dismissed it as just “seeing patterns where no patterns exist.”
“It’s like seeing the blessed virgin in a piece of toast, the restriction sites that she finds are commonly occurring elsewhere in Sars-Cov-2 and in other related viruses and if you were to engineer in restriction sites to manipulate the spike gene, I certainly wouldn’t do it like that, there’s much better ways to do that,” Kaelber said.
Whittaker, who works extensively with coronaviruses that occur in animals, said that the havoc that Sars-Cov-2 causes in the body could raise questions about its origins — but a similar coronavirus found in cats does the same sort of damage.
“It has this wide spectrum of disease outcomes and it’s like nothing we’ve ever seen before but if you look at the disease outcomes in humans and in cats there’s actually a lot of similarities,” Whittaker said.
“[The cat coronavirus] was absolutely naturally acquired. We don’t know how or why but it was absolutely natural… why would anyone design a virus to kill a bunch of cats?” he said. “If it can happen in cats in alphacoronavirus it can also happen with humans in betacoronavirus.”
Other critics noted that the paper was put out by the Rule of Law Society & Rule of Law Foundation — a New York-based group run by accused fraudster Steve Bannon and Chinese dissident and fugitive billionaire Guo Wengui. They said the partnership raises questions about political motivations driving the paper’s release and how the research was funded.
“It does not advance the inquiry. If anything, through its unsound reasoning, its oversold conclusions, and, most important, its sponsorship by Chinese fugitive billionaire [Guo] Wengui, it decreases — not increases — the likelihood the Chinese government will agree to an open and credible forensic investigation of the origins of the virus,” said Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist from Rutgers.
But Whittaker said Yan’s report does offer a detailed explanation on how to grow the virus in a lab, which is sound. While he does lean towards the theory that Sars-Cov-2 occurred naturally, he said it’s too early to completely rule out the potential of it being man made.
He and Dr. Nikolai Petrovsky, an endocrinologist from Australia’s Flinders University, also said Yan’s report provides a solid counterpoint to a March Nature article titled “The Proximal Origin of Sars-Cov-2” that argues there is no way the virus could have been grown in a lab.
“All the tools were there, all the information was there to create the virus, she’s not proving it was created, she’s proving it was possible based on what was available at that time,” said Petrovsky, calling the Nature piece “horribly flawed commentary” that was “political.”
“It’d be even stronger if someone followed the paper” and recreated the virus in a lab based on Yan’s report, he said.
But one of the authors on the Nature article, virologist Dr. Ian Lipkin from Columbia University, told The Post in response that “we’ve explored” the possibility of Sars-Cov-2 being man made and “there’s really nothing else to it.”
“The evidence is not persuasive,” said Lipkin, who worked as an advisor on the feature film “Contagion,” which depicts a pandemic-ravaged world that’s eerily similar to today’s outbreak.
“This is really just shifting focus away from where it needs to be, which is trying to identify how this emerged in nature and what we can do to ensure it never happens again.”
Additional reporting by Isabel Vincent
Hundreds of protesters stage ‘sit in’ at Brooklyn Bridge
Some 500 Black Lives Matter protesters marched onto the roadway of the Brooklyn Bridge Friday night — where they sat down and blocked traffic for about an hour before moving on.
The protesters had gathered at the Barclays Center before taking the bridge.
The group wound up retreating back to Brooklyn about an hour later after a large number of cops massed on the Manhattan side of the bridge and began moving toward them.
No arrests were made, a police spokesman said.
Sheriffs bust indoor Queens wedding with 200 people present
The Sheriff’s Office busted up a massive, social-distance-violating Queens wedding reception with a 200-plus person guest list Friday night, law enforcement sources said.
Dressed in gowns and suits, 246 people had poured into a loading dock on the side of the Elite Palace wedding venue for a night of drinking and partying.
Alcohol was served and no masks were worn, sources said.
New York City sheriff deputies swept in just before midnight to break up the soiree.
The owner was slapped with summonses for disobeying the city’s coronavirus orders, serving liquor without a license and not providing multiple points of entry, sources said.
The risky reception was held as the city warns of an alarming rise of coronavirus cases in swaths of Brooklyn and Queens, with health officials warning that reopening rollbacks could come in the areas if the transmission doesn’t drop in the coming days.
NYC firefighter rescues giant iguana from Astoria apartment fire
As fire rescues go, this one is both heart-warming and cold-blooded.
An FDNY firefighter emerged from an Astoria apartment fire Friday night with a very lucky giant iguana in his arms and a nearly-bigger grin across his soot-covered face.
The fire broke out just before 6 p.m. on the top floor of a three-story apartment building near the corner of 23rd Street and 25th Road, an FDNY spokesperson said.
A hero firefighter managed to locate and save the big, scaly pet even though the third floor — where it lived — was on fire, said photographer Chris Clarke, who snapped the photo.
“When he came out of the building, he had this big smile on face as he was talking the other firefighters,” Clarke said.
“At first I thought he was carrying a cat,” Clarke said.
“Then I realized that’s not a cat — it’s huge!”
The firefighter reunited the lizard with its relieved owner who as waiting outside, according to Clarke.
“They were clearly very happy to have the iguana,” the photographer said.
The fire was placed under control at 7: 10 p.m., according to the FDNY.
One firefighter was transported to Mount Sinai Queens hospital with minor injuries.
The cause of the fire is under investigation.
- Djokovic braced for unhappy Nadal and Roland Garros demons
- California braces for power shutoffs and warm, windy weekend
- Khabib Nurmagomedov’s Teammate Zubaira Tukhugov Misses Weight for UFC 253
- Hundreds of protesters stage ‘sit in’ at Brooklyn Bridge
- Giants power past Padres for key win in doubleheader Game 1
- Rep. Doug Collins has a big idea to prevent Supreme Court packing
- Lakers’ Frank Vogel and Anthony Davis Laud LeBron James’ Dominating Gameplay Against Jamal Murray
- Paul Pierce Says Players Today are Scared of LeBron James
- House Republicans Call on Attorney General Barr to Investigate Recent Spike in Anti-Catholic Hate Crimes
- “It’s Not Going To Be Like a Normal Roland Garros” – Victoria Azarenka Before French Open 2020
Entertainment6 days ago
Danish TV show ‘Ultra Strips Down’ records kids eyeing naked adults
Sports News1 day ago
US Olympian Chloe Dygert crashes over guardrail in cycling accident
Sports News3 weeks ago
Fantasy Football Auction Draft strategy: Tips, advice for spending your 2020 player budget wisely
Sports News3 weeks ago
NBA 2K21 Cover Star Damian Lillard Reveals His Issues With the Game
Sports News5 days ago
Fantasy Football Buy-Low, Sell-High Stock Watch: Leonard Fournette, Stefon Diggs among movers heading into Week 3
Tech4 days ago
iOS 14 basics: how to add widgets to your iPhone’s home screen
Sports News3 weeks ago
NBA playoff bracket 2020: Updated standings, seeds & results from each round
Sports News2 weeks ago
NFL Analyst Takes a Cheeky Dig on Browns Stars Odell Beckham Jr. and Baker Mayfield